Financial Advisor vs Self-Investing: Which is Right for You?

Explore the pros and cons of hiring a financial advisor versus self-investing to find the approach that best suits your financial goals.

By Farther

Deciding whether to manage your own investments or work with a financial advisor is an important choice that affects how you'll build your financial future. While a financial advisor brings expertise to guide complex decisions, managing your own investments puts you in control - but requires more of your time and knowledge.

Let's explore what each path really means for your money and compare the real costs and benefits of getting professional help versus going solo. We'll break down the key factors to help you choose the approach that best fits your goals and situation.

Key Takeaways

  • Financial advisors offer expert advice, handle complex planning, and save you time, but they charge fees that may reduce your returns.
  • Self-investing lowers costs and gives full control over decisions but requires financial knowledge, research skills, and consistent effort.
  • Tools like robo-advisors, stock apps, and online brokers make self-investing easier for beginners with limited experience.
  • Fee-only advisors follow fiduciary standards to act in your best interest; commission-based advisors may favor products tied to their earnings.
  • Your choice depends on your goals, time availability, comfort level with investing alone or needing professional guidance.

Understanding Financial Advisors

A financial advisor serves as your guide to achieving your money goals, helping you navigate complex financial decisions and create a solid plan for your future.

What financial advisors do

These professionals do more than just pick investments. They analyze your complete financial picture - from your current savings to your future dreams - and create a strategy to help you get there. Their services typically include:

  • Retirement planning
  • Tax strategies
  • Estate planning
  • Investment management
  • Creating personalized financial plans based on your goals and risk tolerance

What Is Self-Investing?

Taking control of your own financial future by managing your investments directly is what self-investing entails. Instead of paying a financial advisor, you make your own investment decisions, choose where to put your money, and use investment platforms and tools to execute your strategy.

Tools and platforms for self-investing

To manage your own investments successfully, you'll need the right set of tools. Here are some options to get started and stay on track with your investment goals.

  1. Online Brokers - Platforms like E*TRADE, Fidelity, or Charles Schwab help you buy and sell stocks, ETFs, and other investment types. They often offer low fees and easy account setup.
  2. Robo-Advisors - Services like Betterment or Wealthfront provide automated investment management. They use algorithms to create portfolios based on your goals and risk level.
  3. Stock Market Apps - Tools such as Robinhood or Webull allow quick trades on your phone. Many offer commission-free trading for added savings.
  4. Research Tools - Websites like Morningstar or Yahoo Finance give access to market news, stock analysis, and performance forecasts. These help with making informed investment decisions.
  5. Tax Management Software - Programs like TurboTax can help track gains or losses from investments. This ensures you stay compliant with tax laws while maximizing deductions.
  6. Education Resources - Platforms such as Investopedia teach investing basics to advanced strategies through articles or videos.
  7. Budgeting Tools - Apps like Mint or Personal Capital let you monitor spending alongside your investments, keeping personal finance organized.
  8. Retirement Account Providers - Companies offering Roth IRAs or 401(k)s—like Vanguard—help investors grow long-term savings tax-efficiently.

Skills needed for successful self-investing

You must understand basic financial concepts like stocks, bonds, and market trends. Without this foundation, managing your own investments can lead to costly mistakes.

Successful self-investing also requires strong decision-making skills. You'll need to stay level-headed during market swings and dedicate regular time to research and monitor your investments.

Advantages of Hiring a Financial Advisor

Financial advisors can simplify complex financial decisions. They offer guidance that aligns with your unique goals and needs.

Expert guidance and personalized strategies

Financial advisors can provide individualized strategies to help you meet your specific financial goals. They assess your current financial situation, understand your needs, and create a plan that fits.

This may include asset allocation, retirement planning, or managing an investment account.

These professionals use their experience to reduce risk while aiming for better returns. A financial planner can also adjust strategies if your life changes—like moving jobs or having kids.

Working with one ensures you get advice customized to manage your money effectively.

Holistic financial planning

Looking at every part of your financial life is what holistic financial planning entails. It covers savings, investments, debt, taxes, insurance, and retirement goals. A financial advisor can help create a comprehensive financial plan that matches your needs.

This type of planning ensures all areas work together for your benefit. For example, it may balance paying off loans while growing investments for the future. Working with an advisor helps you stay on track and adjust plans if life changes occur.

Advantages of Self-Investing

When you manage your own investments, you have full control over where your money goes and how it's invested.

Lower fees and costs

Self-investing helps you avoid advisor fees that cut into your returns. Traditional financial advisors typically charge 1% or more of your portfolio each year. Commission-based advisors add extra costs through trades and product sales.

Online platforms and robo-advisors cost less than human advisors but offer less personal guidance. Most self-investing tools have low fees or simple flat-rate pricing. By managing your own money, you'll keep more of what you earn and pay fewer fees along the way.

Greater control over investment decisions

When you manage your own investments, you're in complete control of where your money goes. Every decision is yours, based on your personal goals, values, and research, without needing to align with an advisor's strategy.

Self-investing also gives you the freedom to act quickly. You can adjust your portfolio as soon as market conditions change, without waiting for advisor approval. Many investors find this hands-on approach both satisfying and educational, as it helps them develop a deeper understanding of their investment options.

Factors to Consider When Deciding

Before making your choice, evaluate two crucial factors: how comfortable you are making investment decisions, and how much time you can actually devote to managing your money.

Your financial knowledge and experience

Your comfort level with investing plays a key role in this decision. If you're new to the investment world, a financial professional can provide crucial guidance and help you avoid common mistakes. Their expertise and experience typically lead to better returns, and they'll create a strategy tailored to your specific goals.

Self-investing can be effective if you're confident in making investment decisions on your own. However, it requires dedication to learning about markets, investment strategies, and using various investment platforms.

Keep in mind that mistakes from inexperience could end up costing more than what you'd pay for professional guidance.

Time commitment and availability

Managing your money takes time. Deciding between hiring a financial advisor or self-investing depends on how much time you can dedicate.

  1. A financial advisor saves time by handling decisions for you. They assess your financial situations and offer financial planning that fits your needs.
  2. Self-investing requires more effort and hours. You'll need to research markets, learn about investing, and monitor your investments regularly.
  3. Financial advisors typically get higher fees but free up your schedule. This is helpful if you have a busy job or don't feel comfortable investing alone.
  4. People with more availability might enjoy learning about investing and making their own investment decisions. It gives control over investment choices and the self-satisfaction of learning new skills.
  5. Consider your investment timelines. If you're planning for retirement or need active portfolio management, an advisor's expertise could be valuable for meeting your deadlines.

Hire a Financial Advisor

Managing your investments on your own can be rewarding, but it also comes with risks and time-consuming decisions.

A Farther financial advisor provides expert guidance, personalized strategies, and long-term planning to help you grow and protect your wealth.

Want help deciding which approach works best for you?

Talk to an advisor today.

Conclusion

A financial advisor can offer valuable expertise and guidance, potentially saving you both time and costly mistakes. While self-investing might lower some fees, the professional insights and personalized strategy you get from an advisor often prove worthwhile. Your choice depends on your financial knowledge, investing experience, and how much time you can dedicate to managing your money.

Consider your goals carefully - and remember that even experienced investors often benefit from professional guidance. Whether you choose to work with an advisor or manage your investments yourself, the most important step is getting started on your financial journey today.

FAQs

1. What is the difference between working with a financial advisor and self-investing?

Working with a financial advisor means hiring a professional to manage your money, provide investment advice, and offer financial planning for your future. Self-investing involves making your own decisions about investments without relying on an advisor.

2. Why might someone choose to hire a financial advisor instead of self-investing?

A financial advisor can provide expert guidance, help you navigate complex financial markets, and create strategies tailored to your goals. This is especially useful if you lack the knowledge or experience to manage your own investments.

3. Are there cons to using a financial advisor?

Yes, advisors may charge fees that could be based on a percentage of your net worth or flat rates. These costs might reduce overall returns compared to managing investments yourself.

4. What are the benefits of self-investing?

Self-investing lets you save on advisor fees while gaining the satisfaction of learning about investing and managing your own money—perfect for those who enjoy making their own decisions.

5. Who should consider using robo-advisor services?

Robo-advisors work well for individuals who want low-cost options but still need some automated assistance in managing their investments without hiring traditional advisors.

6. How do I decide which option is right for me: self-investing or hiring an advisor?

Consider factors like your current knowledge of investing, time availability, comfort level with risk management, and whether you'd prefer professional help from an investment or wealth manager versus handling it alone.

Important Disclosure

This document is for informational purposes only. It is educational in nature and not designed to be taken as advice or a recommendation for any specific investment product, strategy, plan feature or other purpose in any jurisdiction, nor is it a commitment from Farther Financial Advisors, LLC or any of its subsidiaries or related entities to participate in any of the transactions mentioned herein. All sources of information used are deemed reliable and accurate at the time of printing. Advisory services are provided by Farther Finance Advisors LLC, an SEC-registered investment advisor. Investing in securities involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Before investing, consider your investment objectives, as well as Farther Finance Advisors LLC’s fees and expenses. Farther Finance Advisors, LLC does not provide tax or legal advice; please consult your tax and legal professionals for guidance on these matters.

Together, we'll take your wealth farther

Our concierge team will connect you with the ideal advisor for your unique goals.

Plan your future with confidence
Start with a complimentary no-obligation consultation
GET STARTED