Will vs Trust: Differences & Which One is Right for You?

Discover the key differences between wills and trusts to make informed decisions for your estate plan.

By Farther

Intimidated by estate planning? Don't be. The process begins with understanding two fundamental tools that can protect your legacy and provide for your loved ones.

Wills and trusts serve distinct purposes in your estate strategy. A will functions as your final instructions, directing who receives your assets after your passing. A trust acts as a protective structure that holds and manages those assets, offering enhanced control over their distribution timing and conditions.

This guide examines which option might best serve your family's needs while potentially saving time, money, and heartache. Your decision between these two powerful tools could dramatically impact how efficiently your assets transfer to beneficiaries and how well your final wishes are honored.

What Is a Will?

A will is an essential estate planning document that details how you want your property and assets distributed after death. In this official document, you name an executor who will manage the distribution according to your wishes, ensuring your belongings go to the intended family members, friends, or charities.

Beyond asset distribution, a will enables you to name guardians for minor children and make arrangements for pets. It provides peace of mind for you and your loved ones by clearly expressing your final wishes about who receives what from your estate.

A will gives voice to your wishes after you're gone.

What Is a Trust?

While wills are important, trusts offer another valuable tool in estate planning. A trust creates a legal arrangement where a trustee manages assets for your beneficiaries, providing control over how and when assets are distributed during your life or after death.

Unlike wills, trusts can bypass probate court, protect assets from creditors, and offer tax advantages. Each trust is established through a document that outlines its terms, management structure, and included assets. With options like revocable and irrevocable trusts, you can tailor your estate plan to meet specific needs and goals.

Key Differences Between a Will and a Trust

The timing of when these documents take effect marks a key difference between wills and trusts. A will only works after your death, while a trust can function during your lifetime. Here's a closer look at their distinctions.

1. Timing of Effect

A will has no power until after you pass away. Everything in your will remains under your control during your lifetime. After death, the will must go through probate before assets transfer to your heirs.

Trusts operate differently, potentially taking effect as soon as you create them. Once you place assets in a trust, it begins working according to its terms, allowing for smoother transfer of assets without waiting for probate.

2. Probate Requirements

Wills and trusts handle legal validation quite differently. After death, your will must be proven valid through probate before assets can be distributed as specified. This probate process often takes time and involves court fees.

A significant advantage of trusts is avoiding probate entirely. Assets properly placed in a living trust transfer directly to beneficiaries upon your death without court involvement. This results in faster distribution and potential savings on legal costs associated with probate.

Understanding these different probate requirements helps when selecting the right estate planning tools. Trusts offer an efficient way to bypass lengthy probate processes while ensuring timely asset distribution according to your wishes.

3. Privacy of the Process

Privacy considerations may influence your choice between wills and trusts. Wills become public record during probate, allowing anyone to access information about your asset distribution and beneficiaries.

Trusts offer greater privacy protection. As private arrangements that avoid probate, trusts keep your asset distribution and beneficiary information confidential. This privacy makes trusts attractive for those who prefer discretion regarding their financial affairs.

For high-profile individuals or those with sensitive family situations, a trust may be preferable due to this confidentiality benefit.

4. Control Over Assets During Life

How you manage assets during your lifetime differs between estate planning options. With a revocable living trust, you maintain control over assets placed in the trust while you're alive.

As the trustee, you can manage and use these assets as you wish. You retain the power to transfer ownership or change the trust's terms. Since this type of trust is revocable, you can modify or dissolve it as needed without major complications.

A revocable living trust takes effect immediately and allows seamless management of your financial assets throughout your life. This arrangement helps ensure long-term financial security while maintaining control over your wealth.

4 Types of Trusts

Estate planning offers several trust options to address different needs. Each type—revocable, irrevocable, special needs, and charitable trusts—serves specific purposes and offers unique benefits.

Understanding these different trust types helps you make informed decisions about your estate plan, creating arrangements that align with your financial goals and family circumstances.

types of trust for estate planning

1. Revocable Trust

A revocable trust, also known as a living trust, can be modified or terminated by the individual who established it, referred to as the grantor.

This adaptability allows the grantor to retain authority over their assets while alive, making it a widely favored option for estate planning.

Assets held in a revocable trust bypass probate, ensuring confidentiality and potentially expediting asset distribution following the grantor's passing. Moreover, establishing such a trust can aid in asset management if the grantor becomes unable to make decisions.

Nonetheless, it's essential to recognize that due to its modifiable or terminable nature, assets included in it may still be considered part of your taxable estate when you pass away.

2. Irrevocable Trust

An irrevocable trust is a type of trust where the terms cannot be changed once it's established. Assets transferred into the trust belong to the trust, not the creator.

This setup ensures that assets are separate from your estate for tax purposes, potentially helping to avoid estate taxes and protect assets from creditors.

Irrevocable trusts allow for asset distribution outside probate, offering greater control over management. They're often used to minimize estate taxes, enable long-term management, or support charitable giving.

Despite their benefits, it's crucial to consider their inflexibility, as once established, the terms cannot be altered.

3. Special Needs Trust

A special needs trust is crafted to improve the quality of life for a person with disabilities while safeguarding their eligibility for government assistance programs like Medicaid and Supplemental Security Income.

This type of trust can be used to manage the financial affairs of someone with physical or mental disabilities, ensuring their long-term care needs are met. The main aim is to preserve assets and provide for the ongoing medical care, housing, and specialized services required by individuals with special needs.

This legal arrangement allows family members or guardians to contribute funds toward supplemental items such as therapies, education, recreation, transportation, and other vital expenses while preserving eligibility for public benefits.

As part of your estate planning process when considering your loved one's future after you're gone, it may be wise to create a special needs trust if they depend on government aid due to their disability.

4. Charitable Trust

A charitable trust is a legal arrangement crafted to enhance philanthropy by including assets for the benefit of a specific charity or cause.

Charitable trusts can be a valuable tool in reducing federal estate tax as assets transferred to the trust are considered part of your estate and may qualify for tax deductions.

It's not simply about giving, but also about strategic financial planning. With thorough estate planning services, individuals can establish a charitable remainder trust, effectively ensuring that their chosen charity receives the remaining assets after beneficiaries' needs are met.

When it comes to navigating the intricacies of estate planning tools, considering whether a charitable trust would align with your philanthropic goals and provide potential tax benefits is crucial.

Pros and Cons of Wills

pros and cons of wills

Wills offer several advantages while also having some limitations to consider. Understanding both sides helps you make informed estate planning decisions.

Advantages of Wills

Wills offer several advantages in estate planning:

  1. Clarity: A will provides clear instructions for how you want your assets distributed after your passing. This can help prevent confusion and disputes among family members.
  2. Flexibility: Wills allow you to designate specific items or amounts of money to individual beneficiaries, tailoring your bequests according to your wishes.
  3. Cost-Effective: Creating a will is typically less expensive than setting up a trust, making it an accessible option for many individuals seeking to plan their estates.
  4. Ease of Creation: Wills are relatively straightforward to create with the assistance of an estate planning attorney, ensuring that your intentions are legally documented.
  5. Nomination of Guardianship: For parents with minor children, a will allows you to nominate guardians who will care for your children if anything happens to you and the other parent.

Disadvantages of Wills

When it comes to wills, there are some drawbacks to consider. Here's a breakdown to help you understand the potential disadvantages:

  1. Probate Process: Wills typically go through probate, which can be time-consuming and expensive, potentially delaying the distribution of assets.
  2. Lack of Privacy: The contents of a will become public record during probate, allowing anyone to access information about the estate and its beneficiaries.
  3. Limited Control Over Assets: Once a will is created, it cannot provide ongoing management or protection for your assets.
  4. Potential Contestation: Wills are more susceptible to legal challenges and contestation from disgruntled heirs, which can lead to prolonged legal battles.
  5. Complex Estates: For individuals with complex estates or family situations, a will may not offer sufficient flexibility or protection for their assets and beneficiaries.
  6. Tax Implications: Wills may lead to higher tax implications for beneficiaries compared to trust arrangements due to capital gains taxes and estate taxes.
  7. Limited Effectiveness for Incapacity: A will does not address the management of assets in case of incapacity, potentially leaving assets vulnerable in such situations.

Pros and Cons of Trusts

Trusts offer flexibility in managing assets and can provide protection from creditors. However, creating a trust may involve higher initial costs and ongoing administrative responsibilities.

pros & cons of trusts

Advantages of Trusts

Trusts offer several advantages over wills, making them a powerful tool in estate planning:

  1. Avoiding Probate: Trust assets do not go through the probate process, allowing for faster distribution of assets to beneficiaries and maintaining privacy as probate proceedings are public record.
  2. Protecting Assets: Trusts can shield assets from creditors and legal claims, ensuring that beneficiaries receive their intended inheritance without interference.
  3. Flexibility in Asset Management: Trustees can manage and distribute assets according to specific instructions, providing more control and oversight than a will.
  4. Planning for Incapacity: Establishing a trust allows for the seamless management of assets if the grantor becomes incapacitated, avoiding potential court intervention.
  5. Minimizing Taxes: Certain types of trusts can help reduce estate taxes and income taxes on trust income, providing tax benefits for both the grantor and beneficiaries.

These advantages make trusts a compelling option for individuals seeking comprehensive estate planning solutions.

Disadvantages of Trusts

Advantages of trusts provide a compelling case for considering this estate planning tool. However, it is essential to weigh these benefits against potential drawbacks:

  1. Complexity: Establishing and managing a trust can be complex and may require professional assistance as trust laws can vary by state.
  2. Cost: Setting up and maintaining a trust can be expensive, involving legal fees, trustee fees, and other administrative costs.
  3. Loss of Control: Once assets are transferred into a trust, the grantor may relinquish some control over them to the trustee, affecting decision-making authority.
  4. Public Record: Unlike wills, some types of trusts don't offer the same level of privacy as they may require public disclosure of their terms and assets.
  5. Funding Challenges: Transferring assets into the trust needs careful attention; overlooking this step could impact the effectiveness of the trust.
  6. Inflexibility: Irrevocable trusts cannot be easily modified or revoked once established, potentially limiting future options for changes in circumstances.
  7. Tax Implications: While trusts can offer tax advantages in some cases, they can also have complex tax rules and implications that demand careful consideration.
  8. Limited Accessibility: Some specialized trusts such as special needs trusts may have restrictions on how funds are used or distributed which could limit flexibility for beneficiaries.

How to Choose Between a Will and a Trust

When deciding between a will and a trust, consider your financial situation, estate planning goals, and tax implications.

Assessment of these factors can help you determine which option best suits your needs.

Assess Your Financial Situation

To decide between a will and a trust, start by evaluating your financial situation. Consider the value of your assets, such as retirement accounts, personal property, and estate assets.

Assessing potential tax implications is crucial in making this decision. Furthermore, think about whether you want control over your assets during your lifetime or if you have complex legal arrangements like a testamentary trust that may need to be included in your estate plan.

Evaluating these aspects will help you determine which option aligns best with your financial circumstances and goals for asset distribution.

Consider Your Estate Planning Goals

Now that you have assessed your financial situation, it's time to think about your estate planning goals.

This involves examining what you want to achieve with the distribution of your assets and how you want to provide for your loved ones after you're gone.

Factors like considering whether a trust is likely or whether a trust may be the better option should be taken into account. Moreover, assessing tax implications and contemplating the right of survivorship are important steps in choosing between a will or a trust.

It all comes down to what kind of trust is common and effective based on your specific needs, as well as how state law plays into transferring property and distributing assets.

Now that you have assessed your financial situation, it’s time to think about what estate planning structures should be included in your estate plans. 

One of the first things to consider is, how you want your assets to be distributed to the people and causes you care about. Consideration should be given for the age of your loved ones and any special support or provisions you want to include to ensure your assets are used in a productive manner. For folks with charitable intent, it will be important to think about they type of impact you want your estate to have on the causes that you want to support.

There are many unique structures and language that can be used within estate documents to ensure your wishes are respected even after your passing. Taking the time to work with a financial planner or estate attorney will allow them to help you shape the estate plan that you want. 

Evaluate Tax Implications

When evaluating tax implications, it is important to understand the tax variances between wills and trusts.

Wills may be subject to estate taxes based on the total value of the assets, while assets in a trust can potentially mitigate estate taxes due to their removal from the taxable estate .

Trusts also offer potential tax advantages for beneficiaries, as they may receive assets with reduced or no tax liabilities compared to those received through a will. Moreover, certain types of trusts, such as charitable trusts, provide specific tax benefits and deductions for both the creator of the trust and their heirs.

In contrast, wills do not offer any direct opportunities for reducing tax burdens the way trusts do. The choice between a will and a trust can significantly impact your estate's overall taxation, so carefully considering your financial situation and consulting with an expert is essential when making this decision.

Hire a Financial Advisor

Deciding between a will and a trust isn’t always straightforward.

The right choice depends on your goals, assets, and family needs. A Farther financial advisor can help you make sense of your options and create a plan that protects your legacy.

Let’s figure it out together—talk to an advisor today.

Conclusion

In the end, choosing between a will and a trust depends on your financial situation and estate planning goals. If you want to avoid probate and keep the process private, a trust might be right for you.

However, if simplicity and flexibility are more important to you, then a will could be the better option. Consider consulting with an estate planning professional to help determine which option aligns best with your needs.

FAQs

1. What's the difference between wills and trusts in estate planning?

The key difference lies in when they take effect: a last will and testament becomes effective after death, while a trust is effective at the time it's created.

2. Can you change the terms of both a will and trust?

Yes, but with limits. A person can alter their will freely, but some trusts cannot be changed once established.

3. How are assets managed in a trust versus a will?

In a trust agreement, chosen trustees manage the assets included in the trust during your lifetime. In contrast, an executor for your estate manages asset distribution as per your last will after your demise.

4. Do all assets require probate?

No! Assets held outside the trust or not specified in a living will generally require probate; however, those placed into an account under either revocable or irrevocable trusts bypass this process.

5. When should I consider creating both a will and trust as part of my estate plan?

Estate planning is critical to ensure smooth asset transition upon death—having both provides additional security by specifying how surviving spouses or other beneficiaries receive these assets.

6. Is there any particular reason why I might need to create a trust instead of just having a living will?

Trust creation largely depends on individual needs—it offers more control over asset distribution timing compared to simply having only one’s last testament.

Important Disclosure

This document is for informational purposes only. It is educational in nature and not designed to be taken as advice or a recommendation for any specific investment product, strategy, plan feature or other purpose in any jurisdiction, nor is it a commitment from Farther Financial Advisors, LLC or any of its subsidiaries or related entities to participate in any of the transactions mentioned herein. All sources of information used are deemed reliable and accurate at the time of printing. Advisory services are provided by Farther Finance Advisors LLC, an SEC-registered investment advisor. Investing in securities involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Before investing, consider your investment objectives, as well as Farther Finance Advisors LLC’s fees and expenses. Farther Finance Advisors, LLC does not provide tax or legal advice; please consult your tax and legal professionals for guidance on these matters.

Together, we'll take your wealth farther

Our concierge team will connect you with the ideal advisor for your unique goals.

Plan your future with confidence
Start with a complimentary no-obligation consultation
GET STARTED